Man City Vs Man United: Player Ratings

Chartdata

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 16, 2024

38 visitor like this post

Share

Man City vs Man United: Player Ratings - A Tactical Breakdown

The Manchester derby is always a spectacle, a clash of titans that leaves fans breathless. This year's encounter between Manchester City and Manchester United was no different, a thrilling match filled with drama, tactical battles, and individual brilliance. Let's delve into the player ratings, analyzing individual performances and their impact on the game's outcome.

Manchester City Player Ratings

Goalkeeper:

• Ederson (8.5/10): Made several crucial saves, including a stunning stop to deny Rashford in the second half. His distribution was, as always, impeccable. A commanding presence in goal.

Defenders:

• Kyle Walker (7.5/10): Solid defensively, dealing effectively with Antony's threat. Showed his attacking prowess with some dangerous runs down the flank.
• Ruben Dias (8/10): A rock at the back. Won almost every aerial duel and made crucial interceptions, demonstrating his exceptional defensive capabilities. A leader at the heart of the City defense.
• John Stones (7.8/10): A composed performance, reading the game well and making timely tackles. His passing accuracy was key to City’s build-up play.
• Nathan Aké (7.5/10): Provided defensive solidity and contributed well to City's attacking transitions. Offered a reliable presence on the left side.

Midfielders:

• Rodri (8.2/10): Dominated the midfield battle. His passing range and defensive work rate were exceptional. A truly commanding performance in the heart of City's midfield.
• Kevin De Bruyne (9/10): A masterclass. His vision, passing accuracy, and creativity were instrumental in City’s attacking play. A constant threat and a deserving Man of the Match candidate.
• Bernardo Silva (8/10): Tireless work rate, constantly pressing and creating opportunities. His movement and link-up play were crucial.

Forwards:

• Jack Grealish (7.5/10): Provided width and caused problems for United’s defense with his dribbling ability. His crossing could have been better, but his overall contribution was positive.
• Erling Haaland (7/10): While he didn't score, his presence was felt. He held the ball up effectively and created space for his teammates. A slightly quieter performance than usual but still an influential figure.
• Julian Alvarez (7.8/10): His energy and movement caused havoc for United's defence. A constant threat with and without the ball, offering a dynamic impact from the bench.

Manchester United Player Ratings

Goalkeeper:

• Andre Onana (7/10): Made some good saves but could have done better on one of City's goals. His distribution was generally accurate.

Defenders:

• Aaron Wan-Bissaka (6.5/10): A solid defensive display, but offered little going forward.
• Lisandro Martínez (7/10): Battled hard against City’s attacking threats, but struggled at times against Haaland's physicality.
• Raphael Varane (7.2/10): A composed performance, generally solid in his defensive duties, but lacked the ability to impose himself in the air.
• Luke Shaw (6.8/10): Offered support in attack, but was occasionally exposed defensively.

Midfielders:

• Casemiro (7.5/10): United's midfield anchor, his defensive work was vital in containing City's midfield dominance, though he couldn’t stem the tide completely.
• Bruno Fernandes (7/10): Showed flashes of brilliance, but his overall performance was inconsistent.
• Mason Mount (6.5/10): Struggled to impact the game significantly. His performance lacked the usual dynamism.

Forwards:

• Marcus Rashford (7.2/10): A constant threat on the counter-attack, forcing several saves from Ederson. His pace was a problem for City’s defense.
• Antony (6.5/10): Tried to make things happen but was largely contained by Walker. His final ball often let him down.
• Jadon Sancho (6/10): Offered little threat and failed to provide support to Rashford. A disappointing performance.

Conclusion

Manchester City's superior tactical approach and individual brilliance proved too much for Manchester United to handle. While United showed moments of resilience and attacking threat, City's dominance in midfield and clinical finishing ultimately secured the victory. This detailed analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the players' performances, offering valuable insight into the tactical nuances of this intense encounter. Remember, these ratings are subjective and interpretations may vary.