Man City Vs Man Utd: Match Player Ratings

Chartdata

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 16, 2024

41 visitor like this post

Share

Man City vs Man Utd: Match Player Ratings - A Tactical Breakdown

The Manchester derby is always a spectacle, and this year's clash between Manchester City and Manchester United was no exception. While the final score may tell one story, a deeper dive into individual player performances reveals a more nuanced narrative. This article provides a detailed analysis of the match, assigning player ratings based on their contribution to the game. We'll explore both tactical successes and failures, providing context to the numbers.

Manchester City Player Ratings

Manchester City dominated possession and created numerous chances, but their clinical finishing was, at times, lacking.

Outstanding Performers:

• Erling Haaland (9/10): Despite not scoring, Haaland's presence was constantly felt. His tireless pressing disrupted United's build-up play, and his hold-up play created space for his teammates. A near-perfect performance even without finding the back of the net.
• Kevin De Bruyne (8.5/10): The orchestrator-in-chief. De Bruyne's vision and passing accuracy were exceptional, dictating the tempo of the game and creating numerous scoring opportunities for his teammates. His set-piece delivery was also a threat throughout.
• Rodri (8/10): A rock in midfield. Rodri's defensive contributions were crucial in shielding the backline and initiating attacks from deep. His passing range and composure were key to City's control of the game.

Good Performances:

• Jack Grealish (7.5/10): Provided consistent threat down the left flank, his dribbling ability causing problems for United's defense. While he didn't score, his contribution to City's attacking play was significant.
• John Stones (7/10): Solid defensively, reading the game well and making crucial interceptions. His ability on the ball also helped City build attacks from the back.

Average Performances:

• Ruben Dias (6.5/10): A relatively quiet game for Dias, though he performed his defensive duties competently. No major errors, but lacked the standout moments of other players.

Manchester United Player Ratings

Manchester United struggled to contain City's attacking prowess, offering little in the way of consistent threat.

Decent Performances:

• Casemiro (7/10): United's best player on the day, Casemiro battled tirelessly in midfield, winning tackles and disrupting City's rhythm. His experience was crucial in a difficult game.
• Aaron Wan-Bissaka (6.5/10): A solid defensive performance against Jack Grealish, minimizing the winger's impact in certain periods.

Below-Par Performances:

• Bruno Fernandes (5/10): A frustrating performance from the Portuguese midfielder, who struggled to influence the game effectively. His passing accuracy was below his usual standards, and he lacked creativity.
• Marcus Rashford (5.5/10): Was largely ineffective against City's defense, failing to create or capitalize on opportunities. A disappointing display from a player usually capable of more.
• Lisandro Martínez (5/10): Struggled to cope with City's movement and pace. He made some important tackles, but his overall performance was unconvincing and he was easily bypassed at times.

Tactical Analysis & Conclusion

Manchester City's dominance in possession and their clinical passing were key to their victory. Their pressing game forced numerous errors from Manchester United, and their ability to retain possession in crucial areas stifled any chances of a United comeback. Manchester United's midfield struggled to control the tempo of the game, and their inability to convert limited opportunities proved costly. The disparity in performance between the two teams was evident throughout the match. Overall, a comprehensive victory for Manchester City, reflecting the gulf in class between the two sides on this particular day. The individual player ratings reflect these tactical disparities.