Man City Vs Man Utd: Player Ratings Review

Chartdata

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 16, 2024

42 visitor like this post

Share

Man City vs Man Utd: Player Ratings Review - A Derby Day Deconstruction

The Manchester Derby. A clash of titans, a battle for bragging rights, and a spectacle that always delivers drama. This year's encounter between Manchester City and Manchester United was no different, leaving fans buzzing (or perhaps groaning, depending on their allegiance) long after the final whistle. Let's dive into a player-by-player ratings review, dissecting individual performances and analyzing the key contributions (and shortcomings) that shaped the game.

Manchester City Player Ratings

Manchester City dominated possession and created numerous chances, showcasing their usual slick passing and clinical finishing. However, United's stubborn defense made it harder than expected.

Goalkeeper: Ederson (8/10)

Ederson was largely untroubled, but his commanding presence and precise distribution were crucial in City's build-up play. A couple of crucial saves showcased his reflexes and prevented any potential upsets. A solid, dependable performance from the City keeper.

Defenders: Walker (7/10), Akanji (7.5/10), Dias (8/10), Ake (7/10)

The City backline was largely impenetrable. John Stones' absence was barely felt thanks to the strong performances of Akanji and Dias, who formed a formidable central defensive partnership. Walker provided his usual attacking impetus down the right, while Ake offered solidity on the left.

Midfielders: Rodri (8.5/10), De Bruyne (9/10), Gundogan (7.5/10)

Rodri controlled the midfield battle with his typical authority, shielding the defense and initiating attacks with pinpoint accuracy. Kevin De Bruyne was, as always, the orchestrator-in-chief, delivering a masterclass of passing and creativity. Gundogan added his usual tireless work rate and intelligent movement.

Forwards: Grealish (7/10), Haaland (9.5/10), Foden (8/10)

Grealish provided width and tireless running, creating opportunities for his teammates. Erling Haaland was, once again, the difference-maker, bagging a brace and showcasing his incredible predatory instincts. Foden, deployed centrally, produced a clever assist and continuously threatened the United defense.

Manchester United Player Ratings

Manchester United fought valiantly, but ultimately couldn't match City's superior firepower and control of the game. Their defensive organization was impressive at times, but their attacking play lacked the incision and creativity needed to trouble City consistently.

Goalkeeper: Onana (7/10)

Onana had a busy afternoon, making several key saves to keep the score respectable. His distribution was also a notable asset, looking to launch quick attacks. He showed great promise and composure under pressure.

Defenders: Wan-Bissaka (6.5/10), Varane (7/10), Martinez (6/10), Shaw (6/10)

United's defense had its moments of brilliance, but also conceded some chances due to lapses in concentration. Varane put in a decent shift, however, Martinez and Shaw struggled at times against City's relentless attacking pressure.

Midfielders: Casemiro (7/10), Mount (6/10), Bruno Fernandes (6.5/10)

Casemiro provided his usual defensive grit and tenacity, winning back possession and breaking up City's attacks. However, the creative spark was lacking in the midfield, with Mount and Fernandes unable to exert enough influence on the game.

Forwards: Antony (6/10), Rashford (6.5/10), Garnacho (7/10)

Antony and Rashford had a few moments of brilliance but generally struggled to impact the game decisively. Garnacho injected some energy and threat from the bench, offering a glimpse of his potential.

Conclusion: A Dominant Display

The Manchester City vs Manchester United derby showcased a clear disparity in quality and performance levels. While Manchester United showed flashes of resilience and determination, Manchester City's superior squad depth, tactical prowess, and clinical finishing proved to be the deciding factors. This match highlights the considerable gap between the two clubs at present, but United will no doubt be looking to bridge that gap in future encounters.