Grading Alabama's South Carolina Win: A Close Call
The Crimson Tide escaped Columbia with a 30-24 win over South Carolina, but it wasn't pretty. While Alabama ultimately emerged victorious, the game exposed some weaknesses that need addressing. Let's break down the performance and grade each aspect:
Offense: B+
While the offense put up 30 points, it wasn't a dominant performance. Jalen Milroe had a solid day, throwing for two touchdowns and running for another, but he also threw an interception that nearly cost Alabama the game. The running game struggled to get going, especially in the first half. The lack of a consistent rushing attack made the offense predictable at times.
Defense: C+
South Carolina's offense was a thorn in Alabama's side throughout the game. The Gamecocks were able to exploit the Tide's secondary, particularly on deep passes. The Alabama defense also struggled to contain South Carolina's running back, MarShawn Lloyd. The lack of pressure on the quarterback also contributed to the Gamecocks' success.
Special Teams: A
Will Reichard had a perfect day, making all four of his field goals and extra points. The kicking game was reliable, and the punting unit also did well. Special teams played a critical role in Alabama's win.
Coaching: B
Nick Saban and his staff deserve credit for making the necessary adjustments in the second half. The offense found its rhythm, and the defense tightened up. However, the game shouldn't have been as close as it was. Some coaching decisions, particularly on defense, were questionable.
Overall: B
The win over South Carolina is a win nonetheless. However, the close call should serve as a wake-up call for the Alabama team. The defense needs to improve its communication and execution, and the offense needs to find consistency in the run game. The Tide has plenty of time to address these issues before facing tougher opponents.
Key Takeaways:
- Alabama's defense is vulnerable. The secondary is a concern, and the lack of pressure on quarterbacks is a major weakness.
- Jalen Milroe needs to be more consistent. His potential is evident, but he needs to limit turnovers and improve his accuracy.
- The offensive line needs to create more running lanes. The running game was inconsistent, making the offense one-dimensional.
This game was a good test for Alabama, highlighting areas that need improvement. While the Tide escaped with a victory, they need to work on their weaknesses if they want to achieve their ultimate goal: a national championship.
