The Smile: Restmateriaal of Volwaardig Album?
The Smile, the supergroup featuring Radiohead's Thom Yorke and Jonny Greenwood alongside drummer Tom Skinner, released their debut album "A Light for Attracting Attention" in 2022. But is it just a collection of leftover Radiohead material, or does it stand as a unique and compelling album in its own right?
The question of "restmateriaal" (leftover material) is a valid one. Yorke and Greenwood have a wealth of experience writing and producing music, and some fans might hear echoes of past Radiohead albums in The Smile's sound. Songs like "The Smoke" and "Free in the Knowledge" feel very much in line with the electronic and atmospheric direction of Radiohead's later work.
However, The Smile also presents a fresh perspective, with a more immediate and energetic feel. Tracks like "Skrting on the Surface" and "Pana-vision" are full of groove and distortion, creating a distinct energy that's different from Radiohead's usual sound. This energy is also present in the live shows, where The Smile's music takes on a new life with Skinner's driving rhythms and Yorke's electrifying stage presence.
So, is "A Light for Attracting Attention" a mere compilation of unused Radiohead ideas? It's hard to deny the undeniable Radiohead influences. But it's also undeniable that The Smile is a unique entity, with a distinct identity and a powerful sound that stands on its own two feet.
While it's natural to compare The Smile to Radiohead, it's important to appreciate the album for what it is: a bold and exciting exploration of sound and emotion by three incredibly talented musicians. Whether you're a longtime Radiohead fan or a new listener, "A Light for Attracting Attention" is worth exploring for its own merits.
Listen to The Smile's "A Light for Attracting Attention" and decide for yourself: is it "restmateriaal" or a full-fledged, independent work?
